Printing PressAI
← Back to front page
Ethics, Law & Policy

Why Fewer People Are Challenging Bad Patents

Original reporting by Electronic Frontier Foundation

Image via Electronic Frontier Foundation

The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) is an administrative court within the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) designed to review the validity of issued patents, most notably through its inter partes review (IPR) process. This crucial safeguard against low-quality patents is facing an unprecedented crisis as the number of IPR petitions filed at the PTAB has collapsed. From 327 petitions in Q3 2025, filings plummeted to just 97 in Q3 2026, alongside a sharp drop in institution rates—the PTAB's decision to hear a challenge—from a historical 66-68% to a mere 41% in fiscal year 2026. This decline signals not an improvement in patent quality, but a profound shift in the USPTO's approach, deterring would-be challengers.

Director's Intervention

Historically, IPR offered a predictable, less expensive alternative to federal court for challenging questionable patents, helping to invalidate thousands of claims that should never have been granted. However, the current USPTO leadership has introduced new layers of uncertainty. Beyond simply declining to institute more petitions, the Director has unprecedentedly vacated at least 29 decisions where the PTAB had *already* agreed to hear a case, often terminating proceedings after parties had invested substantial time and money. This erosion of predictability undermines Congress's intent for IPR, leaving vital defenses against bad patents — often used by "patent trolls" against small businesses and innovators — dangerously weakened, and threatening to increase costly litigation for all.

The precipitous decline in Patent Trial and Appeal Board petitions and institution rates, coupled with unprecedented directorial interventions, signals a profound weakening of a critical safeguard against low-quality patents. What began as an efficient, cost-effective administrative alternative to protracted federal court litigation has become an increasingly unpredictable and unreliable process. This erosion of confidence compels potential challengers to reconsider engaging with the PTAB, leaving a vital mechanism for patent quality control severely compromised.

The Broader Implications The consequences extend far beyond the legal nuances of patent challenges. A dysfunctional IPR system means that more questionable patents, which should never have been granted, will endure. This empowers patent trolls and other entities to weaponize these patents, extracting costly settlements from innovators, small businesses, and non-profits that lack the resources to fight prolonged battles in district court. Such an environment stifles creativity and technological advancement, particularly in sectors like software and internet services where basic functionalities are often claimed by broad, ill-defined patents.

Ultimately, this trajectory undermines the very spirit of innovation Congress sought to protect with the America Invents Act. If challenging bad patents becomes prohibitively expensive and uncertain, risk-taking entrepreneurs and developers will face a higher barrier to entry, potentially leading to market stagnation and reduced consumer choice. Reversing this trend is essential to restoring balance, predictability, and fairness to the patent system, ensuring that it fosters innovation rather than hindering it.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) and its role in challenging patents?
The Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) provides an administrative process called Inter Partes Review (IPR) allowing challenges to questionable patents. It serves as a more cost-effective and faster alternative to expensive federal court litigation for invalidating patents that should not have been granted. Congress established IPRs to ensure a mechanism exists to correct errors made during the patent examination process, particularly for low-quality patents that could otherwise hinder innovation and burden businesses with legal costs.
Why are fewer inter partes review petitions being filed at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board?
Fewer Inter Partes Review (IPR) petitions are being filed at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) because the process has become less reliable. The institution rate, or the likelihood of a challenge being heard, has significantly declined. This change is attributed to current USPTO leadership increasingly refusing to consider challenges, often for reasons unrelated to the merits of the case. This unpredictability and the possibility of instituted proceedings being later terminated deter potential challengers from investing time and money.
What are the consequences of fewer patent challenges being heard by the PTAB?
Fewer patent challenges being heard by the PTAB leads to more low-quality patents remaining in force. This enables patent trolls and others to use these patents as weapons, extracting costly settlements or forcing businesses into expensive federal court litigation. Without an effective administrative review, startups, software developers, and small businesses face increased legal risks and costs, potentially stifling innovation. This undermines Congress's original intent for Inter Partes Reviews to efficiently remove invalid patents from the system.
Intro and outro generated by Printing Press AI from the source article above. Always consult the original reporting for verbatim quotes and primary sources.