EFF Submission to OHCHR Consultation on Child Rights and Safety in the Digital Environment
Original reporting by Electronic Frontier Foundation

The concept of child safety in the digital environment encompasses ensuring young people's well-being and rights online, a discussion the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) contends must be inextricably linked to their offline lives. In its submission to the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), the EFF argues that for millions, digital spaces serve as crucial havens, providing vital safety information, community, and avenues for self-expression not available in their physical environments. Therefore, regulatory efforts that restrict access or features in the name of online safety risk making young people’s lives, in total, *less* safe, by curtailing essential lifelines and opportunities.
A holistic perspective
The OHCHR is preparing a significant report on child rights and safety in the digital environment, acknowledging both its unprecedented opportunities and evolving risks, framed within a full spectrum of children's rights including privacy and participation. Against this backdrop, EFF's submission critiques current global regulatory trends that often disregard young people's speech and privacy, prioritizing parental control over youth empowerment and meaningful involvement. Instead of focusing on limiting access, which can exacerbate privacy risks and curtail development, EFF advocates for systemic interventions: holding tech companies accountable for their design choices and data practices, and ensuring young people are central to decisions that affect their digital lives.
The EFF's submission to the OHCHR underscores a critical imperative: that policies aimed at protecting young people online must adopt a holistic, rights-based framework. Rather than viewing the digital realm as separate from offline life, it highlights the internet's role as a crucial, often life-saving, space for connection, expression, and information access. The core argument is clear: measures that restrict access or curtail fundamental rights, such as privacy and speech, ultimately render young people less safe by denying them vital avenues for development and support. True safety emerges not from limitations, but from addressing systemic issues and empowering youth.
A Systemic Shift
This perspective, if embraced by the OHCHR's upcoming report, holds profound implications for global digital governance. It challenges the prevailing trend of knee-jerk regulatory responses that often prioritize paternalistic control over individual autonomy, pushing for a move beyond mere content moderation to accountability for design choices and business models of tech companies. The emphasis on youth participation, digital literacy, and non-discrimination suggests a future where young people are recognized as rights-holders and active shapers of their digital environments, rather than passive subjects of protection. Such a framework could provide a vital blueprint for future legislation, fostering a more equitable, inclusive, and genuinely safer internet for all.
Frequently asked questions
- What is the United Nations' approach to child online safety and digital rights?
- The UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) views child safety through the full framework of their rights. This includes freedom from violence and exploitation, alongside privacy, access to information, expression, participation, and development. They emphasize that protection and rights are reinforcing, not competing, imperatives. Measures taken for safety must not restrict other fundamental rights, advocating for a balanced and rights-based approach to the digital environment.
- Why is a holistic view crucial for assessing young people's digital safety?
- A holistic view considers young people's entire lives, both online and offline. For many, the digital environment provides a crucial safe space, community, and access to vital information, especially when physical environments are unsafe. Restricting online access, even with marginal safety benefits, can paradoxically make their overall lives less safe by removing their only avenues for support, identity exploration, and autonomy. Therefore, safety assessments must not disconnect digital experiences from broader life contexts.
- How can governments and tech companies enhance online safety without limiting youth rights?
- Instead of restricting access to online services, effective solutions involve addressing systemic risks. This includes holding tech companies accountable for their design choices, data practices, and surveillance-driven business models. Governments should focus on broader interventions that tackle the root causes of harm, promote digital literacy, and ensure equality in access and protection. Crucially, young people themselves must be meaningfully included in the design, governance, and regulation processes that affect their digital environments and rights.